In the spring of ’85, I thought I’d made a profound realization entirely on my own: every guy in his early twenties without a partner feels actual, physical pain from loneliness. Why did I think it was my unique discovery? Because no other guy I knew in Pawtucket was admitting to it, and I certainly wasn’t about to be the first. Since I felt it so acutely, I assumed every other guy in that situation did too, but kept too tight to admit it—ever.
At twenty-one, I was damned proud of myself at times, convinced I was uniquely enlightened and quite the smarty for figuring it all out. That kind of confidence can really wallpaper over your self-doubts. Years later, I found out this ache actually applied to about 99.99% of us. We just never would have admitted it to one another and dared to look soft.
I later learned psychologists had already proven what I'd suspected: loneliness activates some of the same neural pathways as physical pain. No wonder it could ache. If you think that’s melodramatic, a few lines from Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young’s “4 + 20” stand as a perfect testimonial:
A different kind of poverty now upsets my soul
Night after sleepless night I walk the floor and I want to know:
Why am I so alone?
Where is my woman?
That song can still haunt me. Hearing it flashes me back to a time when I lacked the language to understand what I was feeling. I was young and unripe, fumbling my way through life and handling emotions as best I could without a how-to manual. Getting answers was like grabbing at smoke. Being a guy, I dared not ask anyone for solutions, so I grappled alone with it.
From working with young guys in their early twenties at my old job, I know this fumbling in the dark is still happening. Every so often, one of them would come to me wrestling with a question he found horribly embarrassing, wondering about deficits in himself he couldn't figure out or fix. They felt they had to protect their masculinity, so they kept it buried. But on occasion, asking the “old guy” at work was their only shot, if they were brave enough to take it. To the kid, his particular problem was entirely novel and just about himself. To me, it was just the timeless plight of young men, and the only answer was that slow, grinding maturation by trial and error. That was never what they wanted to hear, though. I probably wouldn't have wanted to hear that when I was twenty-one either.
Back in ‘85, the gnawing emptiness inside me felt impossible to pinpoint. That early spring, I wanted a girlfriend, but I couldn't understand why the desire felt so deep, pervasive, and yet evasive whenever I tried to pin it down. It was one of those goddamned emotions young guys just can't grasp—not something tangible like a carburetor you can turn around in your hands to inspect.
Then came the soundtrack that amplified everything.
I had just discovered Luke’s Record Exchange on Broadway in Pawtucket. It was an absolute goldmine for a guy like me—someone who wanted to own every album out there but couldn’t afford to fork over ten or fifteen bucks a pop. Luke Renchan, however, was selling incredible music for just two dollars a record. That made it easy to grab whatever caught my eye. The trick to finding a good one was simple: slide the vinyl out of its sleeve, tilt it into the light to check for any Grand Canyon-sized scratches, and if it looked clean, you scored.
That’s how I found Neil Young’s Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere. I brought it home, set it on the turntable, and dropped the needle.
Uh-oh.
This was the first time I heard Neil sing music that was so deeply confessional, laying bare the raw, unfiltered emotions of a young man. The songs captured everything: restlessness, romantic longing, uncertainty about the future, and the emotional heat young men feel without knowing where it comes from or how to handle it. The album felt like a mirror. I was old enough to experience these heavy, adult feelings, but I didn’t know how to settle them down yet. The music cut right through the haze, revealing an ache for identity, romance, and direction. Finally, I had proof that someone else out there felt exactly what I was feeling—the loneliness and the burning desire for something more.
OK, I thought. I am not the only one.
But it didn’t do a thing to calm me down or provide a remedy. To make matters worse, the music was so good that I kept listening to it on repeat, keeping those raw feelings at the forefront. There was no way I was going to quiet down everything I wanted stilled then.
That same spring, I took Carolyn Fluehr-Lobban’s “Comparative Anthropology” course in Gaige Hall at Rhode Island College. It could have been “Comparative Anthropology of the Rat People of Uganda and the Rise of the Common Market of Europe” for all I cared; I just needed an elective outside my major. It was an accelerated, half-semester course, which meant I started it halfway through March.
I was a tiny bit late to the first class. I walked in, headed up the aisle to the only open seat left, and sat down. Professor Fluehr-Lobban handed me the syllabus and went right back to lecturing.
As I got settled, the girl next to me was poring over her papers. She had a mane of hair that spilled down, hiding her face and nearly pooling on her desk. Out of curiosity, she turned her head toward me and our eyes met.
Wow. Look. At. Her! was my first thought.
She went back to her paperwork, completely unaware of the bomb that had just gone off in my head.
Over the next few weeks, I started chatting her up. Kathy was affable, open, and easy to talk to. After class, we’d walk together toward our respective buildings. I didn’t trail her—no need to look like a stalker—and since we both had somewhere to be, we parted ways as soon as either of us reached our destination.
Each time we met, I noticed all sorts of great traits in her. She was from Cranston but didn’t suffer from that nasal, whiny accent some of the locals had. She was bona fide Italian, and I loved dark hair and brown eyes anyway. She had a wicked sense of humor and was never put off by jokes that made others cringe. She loved Andy Kaufman and got the point of his absurdity. She gnawed Red Twizzlers one after another at 7:00 AM for breakfast (a habit I soon took up). I saw she could wear Army fatigue pants with a sweatshirt and still look hot. I wasn't seeing a single negative.
I still hadn’t found out whether she had a boyfriend. Asking outright would’ve tipped my hand too early. You had to look cool, ya know? In our talks, she never mentioned one and didn’t seem attached. Her stories of what she did over the weekend had me thinking she was mainly home or out with her sisters and friends.
Without realizing it, I started doing something many young people do: lionizing the object of my affection. When I wasn’t with her, I spent my time building her up. I imagined us hitting it off romantically because we were hitting it off so well as friends. I dreamed that if we did, she could, by the sheer power of a relationship, fill those empty parts of me. She’d be the prescription for my ailments. Somewhere along the line, I stopped reacting to who she really was and started reacting to what I imagined she could become to me. I perilously built her up in my mind right alongside my affection for her.
Was I falling in love with her? I was completely ga-ga if she was near me, my entire countenance lit up. OK, I was falling in twenty-one-year-old-guy love, I guess you’d call it.
Being twenty-one in the spring of ‘85, I had this distinct feeling that something was about to happen—that my life was about to take off, the engines were about to fire, and I’d be going in directions that would have me flourishing. I didn’t know how, when, or where, but I sensed a shift coming. I remember standing outside one night leaning on my car, hearing Rush’s "Red Barchetta" floating out of the windows, feeling good and turning my life over in my head, all the while vaguely sensing things were about to come together.
What I couldn’t put my finger on then was a young man’s confidence and anticipation that his life was about to wildly expand. I felt like there was a starting pistol about to go off; I was bound up with pep, ready to bolt off the line. It was my turn now. Springtime easily amplifies that eagerness and optimism... especially walking alongside pretty girls with thick hair.
I was having a great time palling around with Kathy at RIC. I genuinely enjoyed her. But a part of me nagged: C’mon, you pussy, it’s high time you asked her out!
After class ended one Thursday, Kathy and I were walking down the stairwell alone toward the front of Gaige Hall. I asked if she was doing anything that weekend. Before she could answer, I mentioned there’d be a Police/reggae cover band playing outside the Hot Club by the river in Providence, and that I was planning to go.
“I’m going… and… I’d like to take you with me. Like a date.”
She stopped walking. Her face looked genuinely astonished when she turned and said, “Oh... Uh... I’m going out... with my boyfriend.”
THUD!
Fuck... FUCK... FUCKKKKKK! my brain screamed.
The very next thought I had was: Don’t show it! Don’t show disappointment! Keep a poker face... look cool... stay cool!
I think I managed to do so, mostly. I told her, “Oh, OK... cool... I was just thinking... ya know.”
We parted outside of Gaige, each heading to different buildings. During my next class, sitting in psych, I didn't pay a single bit of attention to Dr. Cousins. I just kept turning what had happened over and over in my head, feeling completely crushed.
I did eventually figure myself out weeks later. I told myself: You stupid son of a bitch... you built her up in your head so high because it felt good and was such fun. No wonder you feel crushed—you fell from a stratospheric height YOU raised yourself to.
Finishing off the last few weeks at RIC before summer break was tough but manageable. I kept up the poker face when I ran into Kathy, though I still lamented the fact that she was out of reach. A second thought eventually cropped up: What if she wasn't attracted to me to begin with, boyfriend or not? That was a real possibility. Well, at the very least, she liked me—just not like-liked me.
The summer break of ‘85 had me spending more time with my local droogs in Pawtucket, hanging out in Slater Park, the Pit, and making our weekly treks to JR’s Fastlane on Friday nights. As time went on, Kathy slowly drifted out of my mind.
The “Pit” was a deeper valley of the woods by the Ten Mile River, just back of the Pinecrest neighborhood. It became our go-to spot to hold keg parties, build seven-foot bonfires, and get good and blotto. I was completely sure the neighbors could hear us and see the fire deep in the woods, but for some reason, the cops never showed up. I had settled back into my hometown routine, distracted and comfortable.
A girl named Kimmy started coming to those keggers. I hadn't known her previously, as different crews from all around Pawtucket and Seekonk would show up. She had French-girl bangs, and one night she was sitting on a log near the bonfire all by herself because her two friends had left for a run to the packy.
I looked at her with that tilted-head, captivated-boy gaze that’s so easily read by anyone watching. Look at him! He LIKES her!
Huh… she’s cute, I thought to myself.
I walked over to her, took a spot on the log, and said, “Hi!”
It’s funny how I didn’t once think of Kathy while talking to Kimmy, looking at her face, her hair... everything. Once I zeroed in on her, everyone else dropped away. Kathy faded further into the background.
Speaking of stupid gazes, decades later I attended my 40th high school reunion from St. Ray’s. By the end of the night, we had all drifted into a corner of Donald Anthony’s Hose Company #6 to poke through our old yearbook. We were asking about those who hadn’t shown up, wondering where everyone had finally ended up, when Gary, an old classmate, turned to Linda standing beside me and blurted out a confession.
“Linda, you didn’t know it then, but I was crushing on you in the worst way for the longest time back then.”
Linda was visibly shocked—in a good way. She said she’d had no idea at all that he felt that way about her all those years ago.
The conversation shifted, but I noticed Gary’s face after he made that reveal. He kept trying to catch Linda’s eye again. I could see the excitement, the hope... right there on his face. I can bet some of those old thoughts were the expectant dreams he had about her, too.
I get it, I thought to myself as I watched him. He hadn’t seen her in all these years, and those old feelings came rushing right back the moment he saw her again. Linda, unfortunately, was thoroughly married with three kids.
Had my Kathy shown up, I’d be doing the exact same thing. Looking at her, thinking, Well, maybe? Possibly?
I didn’t judge Gary in the least. All those people in the past we had the hots for never really go away.
I know, Gary. I know.









